Tuesday, February 17, 2015

BCDA Versus CJHDevCo: The Final Decision

                The arbitration trial court (PDRCI) had already issued their decision about the dispute between Bases and Conservation Development Authority (BCDA) and Camp John Hay Development Corp. (CJHDevCo). To settle the problem, the court made a win-win solution which the both parties will gain benefits. They  ordered CHJDevCo to  return the properties to the government. It means that the private investors should leave Camp John Hay that they developed for more than one decade. The court can’t determine who first violated  the 2008 RMOA. So, they decided to reject the request of the government agency. The BCDA can’t get the rental payment that they are asking from the investor worth 3.4 billion pesos. Instead, the government agency needs to pay CJHDevCo worth 1.42 billion pesos.

                CJHDevCo Chairman Robert Soprepena welcomed and respected the decision of the PDRCI although it is against his will to vacate Camp John Hay. As a developer, he fully developed and made some major changes in Camp John Hay. He is hoping that the BCDA would comply the decision of the court. His only request to BCDA is let the lessors and locators would continue their operation in Camp John Hay. Aside from that, he asked the agency to take care the 400,000 trees within the area. See, who says that Sobrepena is just thinking about his business? In his last days in Camp John Hay, he is still protecting the people who are working  there. And of course, he has also a concern about the nature or the environment. How about BCDA President Aenel Casanova? He says that they want to take over Camp John Hay for the benefits of the people because CJHDevCo is not paying their rental fee to the government.

                 If we will back to my previous article, they had been delayed with their rental fee because they confronted some problems with their operation. But it doesn’t mean that they don’t have an intention to pay; it will just be delayed. Other BCDA officers had been agreed with this kind of agreement. So, Casanova should blame those officers for giving a favor to the investor.  Instead to help CJHDevCo with their struggle, the BCDA harassed them for delaying the permit that they need. Until Arnel Casanova filed an estafa case against Sobrepena.  

                Now, that the court has already released their decision; how can the BCDA handle properly the Camp John Hay? The CJHDevCo built a lot of recreational and facilities including 5 star hotel out there. Do they have enough experience to manage it? a business there? Do they have already a concrete plan to protect the 400,000 trees grown in that area? How can they develop the area if there are projects and transactions that could not be finished because of their personal grievances against Soprepena.Do they have already other private investor who are willing to become their business partner. If this is the case, BCDA has hidden agenda that’s why they kicked out CJHDevCo in Camp John Hay. Hmm...





No comments:

Post a Comment